Discursive-Material Struggles over Legitimate Heroism
PDF (OPEN ACCESS)

Keywords

memorialscape
floating signifier
discursive-material memorial assemblage
Estonia
Nazi Germany
USSR
heroism
memorialization

Categories

How to Cite

Carpentier, Nico, Ruth-Helene Melioranski, Pille Runnel, and Inês Moreira. 2022. “Discursive-Material Struggles over Legitimate Heroism: A Visual Essay on Floating Signifiers and Their Materiality in the Estonian Second World War Memorialscape”. Membrana – Journal of Photography, Theory and Visual Culture 7 (1-2):1–36. https://doi.org/10.47659/mj-v7n1-2id123.

Abstract

Through a combination of historical research and a series of research visits, this visual essay reflects on how Estonian memorials, related to the Second World War; are discursive-material assemblages, that function as floating signifiers. Grounded in a post-structuralist theorization of contingency, overdetermination and discursive struggle – particularly inspired by Laclau and Mouffe’s (1985) work – the notion of floating signifiers captures the significatory diversity of key concepts which have become integrated in different (and competing) discourses. By extending this framework to recent theoretical expansions that aim to validate both the discursive and the material (Carpentier, 2017), also the floating of discursive-material memorial assemblages can be incorporated into this analysis.

This article, in particular, focusses on the discursive-material struggles over the articulation of the Estonian Second World War hero in the Estonian memorialscape, at a time when the Estonian government has been removing a considerable number of Soviet memorials from the Estonian public space (and plans to remove more). Beginning with the argument that not every Estonian Second World War memorial has been subjected to this discursive-material struggle, we then analyse the discursive-material struggle over the Soviet hero and the Waffen-SS hero, together with the remarkable absence of memorializations of the independent Estonian (nationalist) hero. In a case study, we zoom in on how a prestigious military decoration, the Cross of Liberty, becomes a significant illustration of the workings of the floating signifier, playing a role in both mainstream and radical-right-wing discourses about the Estonian hero during the Second World War. In our conclusion, we reflect about the absence of closure on what is the past, present and future of Estonia, and the ethical concerns that this absence raises.

https://doi.org/10.47659/mj-v7n1-2id123
PDF (OPEN ACCESS)

References

Althusser, Louis. 1982. “Contradiction and Overdetermination.” In For Marx, 87–128. London: Verso.

Bale, John. 2006. “How Much of a Hero? The Fractured Image of Roger Bannister.” Sport in History 26 (2): 235–247.

BBC News. 2002. “Estonia removes SS monument.” July 24, 2002. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/2148732.stm.

BBC News. 2004. “Estonia unveils Nazi war monument.” August 20, 2004. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/3585272.stm.

Bellentani, Federico. 2021. The Meanings of the Built Environment: A Semiotic and Geographical Approach to Monuments in the Post-Soviet Era. Berlin: De Gruyter.

Best, Latrica, and W. Carson Byrd. 2015. “All Marked-Up in the Genetic Era: Race and Ethnicity as ‘Floating Signifiers’ in Genetic and Genomic Research.” Genetics, Health and Society 16: 45–69.

Bruggemann, Karsten, and Andres Kasekamp. 2008. “The Politics of History and the ‘War of Monuments’ in Estonia.” Nationalities Papers 36 (3): 425–448.

Carpentier, Nico. 2011. “Ideological Model of War. Discursive Mediations of the Self and the Enemy.” In Creating Destruction Constructing Images of Violence and Genocide, edited by Nancy Billias and Leonhard Praeg, 13–38. Amsterdam: Brill/Rodopi.

Carpentier, Nico. 2017. The Discursive-Material Knot: Cyprus in Conflict and Community Media Participation. New York: Peter Lang.

Carpentier, Nico. 2022. “The Dislocation of the Empty Signifier Freedom as a Tool in Global Political Struggles: A Case Study on RT’s Mini-Series How to Watch the News.” Javnost – The Public 29 (1): 66–81.

Carr, Gillian. 2012. “Examining the Memorialscape of Occupation and Liberation: A Case Study from the Channel Islands.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 18 (2): 174–193.

Cole, Michael. 2023. “Estonia Begins Replacing Soviet War Grave Markers with ‘Neutral’ Ones.” ERR, January 12, 2023. https://news.err.ee/1608847681/estoniabegins-replacing-soviet-war-grave-markers-withneutral-ones.

Conesa-Sevilla, Jorge. 2018. “‘Nature’: An Empty Signifier.” In Advances in Psychology Research 135, edited by Alexandra M. Columbus, 169–186. New York: Nova Science.

Coombe, Rosemary J. 1992. “The Celebrity Image and Cultural Identity: Publicity Rights and the Subaltern Politics of Gender.” Discourse 14 (3): 59–88. Curtis Jr., L. Perry. 2001. Jack the Ripper and the London Press. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.

Davida, Grupo. 2015. “Trafficking as a Floating Signifier: The View from Brazil.” Anti-Trafficking Review 4: 161–166.

Estonian Centre for Architecture. 2020. “Maarjamae Memorial Complex.” https://estonianarchitecture.com/project/maarjama%CC%88e-memorial/.

Estonian Ministry of Foreign Affairs. 2009. “The Cross of Liberty and the Monument to the War of Independence in Tallinn.” Estonia Today. Fact Sheet April 2009. Tallinn: Estonian Ministry of Foreign Affairs. http://www.vm.ee/estonia/kat_509/pea_172/10420.html. (still available at https://web.archive.org/web/20090703131835/ http://www.vm.ee/estonia/kat_509/pea_172/10420.html.)

Estonian War Museum. 2022. “Tank T-34/85 of Narva relocated into the Estonian War Museum.” 16 August, 2022. https://esm.ee/for-visitors/news/tank-t-34-85-ofnarva-relocated-into-the-estonian-war-museum.

Farkas, Johan, and Jannick Schou. 2018. “Fake News as a Floating Signifier: Hegemony, Antagonism and the Politics of Falsehood.” Javnost – The Public 25 (3): 298–314.

Garlen, Julie C. 2020. “Innocence.” In The Sage Encyclopedia of Children and Childhood Studies, edited by Daniel Thomas Cook, 968–971. London: Sage.

Grady, John. 1991. “The Visual Essay and Sociology.” Visual Sociology 6 (2): 23–38.

Grady, John. 1996. “The Scope of Visual Sociology.” Visual Sociology 11 (2): 10–24.

Gunter, Aleksei. 2004. “Riot police help remove controversial WWII monument.” Baltic Times, September 9, 2004. https://www.baltictimes.com/news/ articles/10835/.

Hall, Stuart. 1997. “Race, the Floating Signifier: What More Is There to Say about ‘Race’?” In Selected Writings on Race and Difference, Stuart Hall, edited by Ruth Wilson Gilmore and Paul Gilroy, 359–373. Durham: Duke University Press.

Hansen, Liina. 2011. Eksperdihinnang Malestise Tunnustele Vastavuse Kohta: Beti Linaait [Expert Assessment of the Compliance with the References of the Memorial: Beti Linaait]. Tallinn: Eesti Kunstiakadeemia. https://register.muinas.ee/file/architecture/1045.pdf.

Hiio, Toomas. 2021. “The History of Monuments and Memorials at Maarjamae 1940–1990.” In Propaganda, Immigration, and Monuments: Perspectives on Methods Used to Entrench Soviet Power in Estonia in the 1950s–1980s, edited by Meelis Saueauk and Meelis Maripuu, 181–227. Tartu: University of Tartu Press.

Howarth, David. 1998. “Discourse Theory and Political Analysis.” In Research Strategies in the Social Sciences, edited by E. Scarbrough and E. Tanenbaum, 268–293. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Jin, Justin. 2019. “Estonia.” Holocaust Remembrance Project. 2019. https://www.holocaustremembranceproject.com/Countries/Estonia

Kaasik, Peeter. 2011. “Summary: Ethnic Estonian Units in the Soviet Army during the Period 1940–1956.” In Vaeteenistusest Eestis ja Eestlastest Vaeteenistuses, Eesti Sojaajaloo Aastaraamat [Military Service in Estonia. Estonians in the Military Service, Estonian Yearbook of Military History] 1 (7), edited by Toomas Hiio, 152–157. Tallinn-Viimsi: Eesti Sojamuuseum / Kindral Laidoneri Muuseum: Tallinna Ulikooli Kirjastu.

Kattago, Siobhan. 2008. “Commemorating Liberation and Occupation: War Memorials Along the Road to Narva.” Journal of Baltic Studies 39 (4): 431–449.

Kavaliauskas, Vilius. 1998. Řady a Vyznamenani: Estonsko, Lotyšsko, Litva, 1918–1940 [Orders and Decorations: Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, 1918–1940]. Brno: Moravske zemske muzeum.

Kazharski, Aliaksei, and Andrey Makarychev. 2022. “From the Bronze Soldier to the ‘Bloody Marshal’: Monument Wars and Russia’s Aesthetic Vulnerability in Estonia and the Czech Republic.” East European Politics and Societies and Cultures 36 (4): 1151–1176.

Kook, Urmet. 2022. “National Archive finds streets named after Red Army soldiers inappropriate.” ERR, November 24, 2022. https://news.err.ee/1608798940/national-archive-finds-streets-named-after-red-armysoldiers- inappropriate.

Kraft, Ulle. 2013. “20. Sajandi Esimese Poole Ajaloosündmuste Jaadvustamisest Ohvrite Hauamonumentidega: Parnu Vana Pargi Ühishaua ja Malestusmargi Teemaline Juhtumiuuring.” In Eesti Sojaajaloo Aastaraamat [Estonian Yearbook of Military History] 3: 200–231. http://publications.tlu.ee/index.php/eymh/issue/view/60.

Kuusik, Argo. 2021. “The Destruction of Monuments from the Period of Independence in the Estonian SSR.” In Propaganda, Immigration, and Monuments: Perspectives on Methods Used to Entrench Soviet Power in Estonia in the 1950s–1980s, edited by Meelis Saueauk and Meelis Maripuu, 139–179. Tartu: University of Tartu Press.

Laaneranna Municipal Council and Government. 2021. “In memoriam Tiit Madisson 04.06.1950–21.06.2021.” Laaneranna Teataja, June 21, 2021. https://ajaleht.laaneranna.ee/2021/06/21/in-memoriam-tiit-madisson-04-06-1950-21-06-2021/.

Laar, Mart. 1992. War in the Woods: Estonia’s Struggle for Survival 1944–1956. Washington: Compass Press.

Laclau, Ernesto, and Chantal Mouffe. 1985. Hegemony and Socialist Strategy. London: Verso.

Laclau, Ernesto. 2005. On Populist Reason. London: Verso.

Lehti, Marko, Matti Jutila, and Markku Jokisipila. 2008. “Never-Ending Second World War: Public Performances of National Dignity and the Drama of the Bronze Soldier.” Journal of Baltic Studies 39 (4): 393–418.

Makarychev, Andrey S. 2012. “Human Security as a ‘Floating Signifier’: Russia’s Reinterpretation of the Concept.” In National, European and Human Security, edited by Mary Kaldor, Mary Martin and Narcis Serra, 152–166. London and New York: Routledge.

Maripuu, Meelis. 2006. “The Execution of Estonian Jews in the Local Detention Institutions in 1941–1942.” In Estonia, 1940–1945: Reports of the Estonian International Commission for the Investigation of Crimes Against Humanity, edited by Toomas Hiio, Meelis Maripuu and Indrek Paavle, 651–660. Tallinn: Estonian Foundation for the Investigation of Crimes Against Humanity.

Melchior, Inge, and Oane Visser. 2011. “Voicing Past and Present Uncertainties: The Relocation of a Soviet World War II Memorial and the Politics of Memory in Estonia.” Focaal – Journal of Global and Historical Anthropology 59: 33–50.

Minnik, Taavi. 2014. “The Establishment of ‘Drumhead’ Courts Martial and their Actions in the Estonian War of Independence 1918−1919.” Juridiskā Zinātne / Law 7: 99–112.

Nikolajev, Juri. 2022. “Small gathering marks 3 months since Narva’s T-34 tank monument removal.” ERR, November 16, 2022. https://news.err.ee/1608790846/small-gathering-marks-3-months-since-narva-s-t-34-tank-monument-removal.

North, Michael. 2015. The Baltic: A History. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Peegel, Mari. 2009. “Parnus avati malestusmark hukatud juudi lastele.” ERR, November 15, 2009. https://www. err.ee/1608963901/politsei-pidas-kinni-tapmiseskahtlustatava-18-aastase-noormehe.

Plakans, Andrejs. 2011. A Concise History of the Baltic States. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Republic of Estonia Government. 2022. “Monuments with Soviet war symbols in Narva have been removed.” August 16, 2022. https://valitsus.ee/en/news/monuments-soviet-war-symbols-narva-have-beenremoved.

Smith, David J. 2008. “‘Woe from Stones’: Commemoration, Identity Politics and Estonia’s ‘War of Monuments’.” Journal of Baltic Studies 39 (4): 419–430.

State Chancellery. 2022. “Riigikantselei tooruhm keskendub okupatsioonivoimu sumboleid kandvatele hauatahistele ja malestusmarkidele.” July 26, 2022. https://riigikantselei.ee/uudised/riigikantselei-tooruhm-keskendub-okupatsioonivoimu-sumboleid-kandvatele-hauatahistele-ja.

Taylor, Hugh Page. 1986. Uniforms, Organization, and History of the Waffen-SS. Volume V. San Jose: James Bender Publishing.

Tomanić-Trivundža, Ilija, and Andreja Vezovnik. 2021. “‘Symbolic Photographs’ as Floating and Empty Signifiers: Iconic Transformation of News Photography.” Journal of Language and Politics 20 (1): 145–161.

Torfing, Jacob. 1999. New Theories of Discourse: Laclau, Mouffe and Žižek. Oxford: Wiley.

Tošić, Jelena. 2022. “Populist Variations on Migration: Floating Signifiers of Mobility in the Context of the ‘Balkan Route’ and the COVID-19 Pandemic.” Journal of Balkan and Near Eastern Studies 24 (3): 542–556.

Tumarkin, Nina. 2003. “The Great Patriotic War as Myth and Memory.” European Review 11: 595–611.

Turovski, Marcus. 2022. “Monuments committee recommends keeping Tehumardi Memorial.” ERR, November 23, 2022. https://news.err.ee/1608798001/monuments-committee-recommends-keepingtehumardi-memorial.

van den Berg, Cilliers. 2016. “Histerie en Perversie (deel I): Enkele teoretiese opmerkings oor Slagofferskap binne Traumadiskoerse [Hysteria and Perversion (part I): Some Theoretical Comments on Victimhood within Trauma Discourses].” Tydskrif vir Geesteswetenskappe 56 (2-2): 693–709.

Van Gorp, Baldwin. 2021. “Face Masks as Floating Signifiers during the COVID-19 Pandemic in Belgium.” Visual Studies 36 (2): 124–132.

Vilgats, Ester. 2022. “Parnu removes Soviet monument from Old Park, begins relocating remains.” ERR, August 8, 2022. https://news.err.ee/1608678922/parnuremoves-soviet-monument-from-old-park-beginsrelocating-remains.

Walter, Hannes. 1998. EESTI TEENETEMARGID. Estonian Orders and Decorations. Tallinn: Miniplast Pluss.

Whyte, Andrew. 2018. “Russian embassy blasts Lihula World War Two monument reinstallation.” ERR, September 3, 2018. https://news.err.ee/858342/russianembassy-blasts-lihula-world-war-two-monumentreinstallation.

Whyte, Andrew. 2022. “Estonian government relocates Narva tank monument.” ERR, August 16, 2022. https://news.err.ee/1608685888/estonian-governmentrelocates-narva-tank-monument.

Williamson, Gordon. 2004. The Waffen-SS (3): 11. to 23. Divisions. Oxford: Osprey.

Wilson, Paul. 2015. “Monumental Indifference in Tallinn.” Public Art Dialogue 5 (2): 170–190.

Wright, Helen. 2022. “Narva tank arrives at Estonian War Museum.” ERR, August 16, 2022. https://news.err.ee/1608686764/narva-tank-arrives-at-estonian-warmuseum.

Zeltser, Arkadi. 2018. Unwelcome Memory: Holocaust Monuments in the Soviet Union. Jerusalem: Yad Vashem.

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Copyright (c) 2023 Membrana Institute and the author(s).